If you're a startup founder or early employee who's borrowed money to exercise options or invest in your company, you need to know about interest tracing. This obscure tax rule could turn what you thought was deductible interest into a costly mistake — and most people don't even know it exists.

Let's break down what interest tracing is, why it matters for startup equity holders, and how to navigate it without getting blindsided by the IRS.

The Quick Primer: What Is Interest Tracing?

Interest tracing is the IRS's way of connecting the dots between borrowed money and how you actually use it. Just because you take out a loan doesn't automatically mean the interest is deductible — the IRS cares what you do with that money.

‍

Here's the basic rule: The tax treatment of interest follows the use of the borrowed funds, not the type of loan or what secures it.

‍

Why this matters for startup folks: If you borrowed money to exercise stock options or buy company shares, that interest might be investment interest (with limited deductibility) rather than the more generous business interest deduction you might expect.

‍

The Startup Scenarios Where Interest Tracing Bites

‍

1. Option Exercise Loans

The situation: You take out a loan to exercise your stock options before an exit or fundraising round.

‍

The tracing issue: Even if you secure the loan with your home or other assets, the IRS treats this as investment interest because you used the money to acquire investment property (your company stock).

‍

Tax impact: Investment interest deductions are limited to your investment income for the year. Any excess carries forward, but it might take years to fully utilize.

‍

‍

2. Secondary Sale Bridge Loans

The situation: You borrow money to cover taxes on a secondary sale while waiting for the transaction to close.

‍

The tracing reality: If you're borrowing against future sale proceeds to pay taxes on that same sale, the interest often gets classified as investment interest.

‍

The gotcha: Many founders assume this is just "tax planning" debt with fully deductible interest. Not necessarily. It's likely classified as investment interest, which means your deduction is limited to your investment income for that year. No investment income? No deduction (though it carries forward to future years).

‍

‍

3. Mixed-Use Borrowing

The situation: You take out a line of credit and use some for personal expenses, some for option exercises, and some for other investments.

‍

The complexity: Now you need to trace each dollar to its use. $100K for option exercise = investment interest. $50K for home improvements = potentially deductible as qualified residence interest. $25K for credit card payoff = personal interest (not deductible).

‍

‍

4. Refinancing Complications

The situation: You refinance a mortgage and use the cash-out proceeds to exercise options.

‍

The surprise: The portion of mortgage interest related to the cash-out funds becomes investment interest, not qualified residence interest.

‍

Real-world impact: You might lose the mortgage interest deduction on a significant portion of your loan.

‍

The Documentation Nightmare

Interest tracing requires meticulous record-keeping. The IRS expects you to trace funds from loan to use, and "commingling" funds in accounts makes this exponentially harder.

‍

What you need to track:

• Exact loan amounts and dates
• How funds moved between accounts
• What each dollar was specifically used for
• Dates of all transactions
• Supporting documentation for each use

‍

‍

The commingling problem: Put loan proceeds in your checking account with other money? Now you need to trace withdrawals using methods like "first in, first out" or average cost basis. It gets messy fast.

‍

Strategic Planning to Avoid Interest Tracing Headaches

‍

1. Segregate Borrowing by Purpose

Best practice: Use separate loans for separate purposes. Don't mix investment-related borrowing with personal or business borrowing.

‍

Example: Instead of one large line of credit for everything, consider:

• A securities-based loan specifically for option exercises
• A separate mortgage refinance for personal needs
• Business credit lines that stay business-only

‍

‍

2. Timing Considerations for Exercise Loans

The strategy: Consider the timing of when you exercise options relative to when you plan to sell.

‍

Key insight: If you're exercising close to an exit, the investment interest limitation might not matter much since you'll have investment income to offset it when you sell.

‍

But if you're exercising years before an exit: Those interest deductions might be limited for years, reducing their value significantly.

‍

‍

3. Alternative Structures to Consider

83(b) + early exercise: Instead of borrowing to exercise later, consider exercising early when the fair market value is low (reducing exercise cost) and filing an 83(b) election.

‍

Cashless exercises: If available, these avoid the borrowing issue entirely, though they result in fewer shares.

‍

Seller financing: In secondary sales, sometimes sellers will finance part of the transaction, which can create different interest tracing dynamics.

‍

The State Tax Complications

Interest tracing isn't just a federal issue. States have their own rules, and they don't always align with federal treatment.

‍

California quirk: California doesn't allow investment interest deductions at all, regardless of federal treatment.

‍

New York complexity: New York has its own interest tracing rules that sometimes diverge from federal rules.

‍

Multi-state issues: If you live in one state but your company is incorporated elsewhere, or if you move states during the holding period, things get even more complex.

‍

Common Mistakes That Trigger Audits

‍

1. Massive Investment Interest Deductions

Red flag: Claiming huge investment interest deductions when you have minimal investment income raises audit flags.

‍

Why it happens: Founders exercise millions in options, pay hundreds of thousands in interest, but don't sell shares (so no investment income to offset).

‍

‍

2. Inconsistent Loan Classifications

The problem: Treating the same loan as mortgage interest on one return and investment interest the next year.

‍

How it happens: Refinancing or changing use of proceeds mid-stream without updating tax treatment.

‍

‍

3. Poor Documentation

Audit killer: Not being able to prove how loan proceeds were used or when funds moved between accounts.

‍

The IRS position: If you can't trace it, they'll often disallow the most beneficial treatment.

‍

Planning Strategies for Current Holdings

‍

If You Already Have Interest Tracing Issues:

Clean it up going forward: Start segregating different types of borrowing now, even if past years are messy.

‍

Document everything: Create a clear audit trail for any new borrowing or use of existing credit lines.

‍

Consider amendments: If you've been treating interest incorrectly, consider whether amended returns make sense before the IRS finds the issue.

‍

‍

If You're Planning Future Borrowing:

Design the structure first: Before you borrow, plan how you'll use funds and what the tax treatment should be.

‍

Keep it simple: The more complex your borrowing structure, the more likely you are to create tracing problems.

‍

Get advice upfront: Interest tracing issues are much easier to prevent than to fix after the fact.

‍

The Bottom Line

Interest tracing might sound like an obscure tax technicality, but for startup founders and employees who borrow to exercise options, it can have massive financial implications. The difference between business interest, investment interest, and personal interest can mean tens or hundreds of thousands of dollars in tax benefits.

‍

The key is planning ahead. Once you've borrowed money and used it for various purposes, your options become limited. But with proper structuring and documentation from the start, you can often achieve the tax treatment you want while staying on the right side of the IRS.

‍

The takeaway: Don't assume all interest on startup-related borrowing is treated the same way. The IRS will trace where your money went, and the tax treatment follows the money — not your intentions or the type of loan you took out.

‍

‍

—

‍

‍

Dealing with complex borrowing structures around your equity compensation? Interest tracing rules can be incredibly nuanced, especially when combined with other startup tax issues like QSBS, AMT, and state tax considerations. Consider working with a tax advisor who specializes in startup equity before taking on significant debt for option exercises or other equity-related transactions.

‍